The Pinpoint Press, with Rick Newman

The Pinpoint Press, with Rick Newman

Pinpoint Markets

These Numbers Say There’s No AI Stock Bubble

Some people think the dot-com bust is happening again. Here’s the optimistic case.

Rick Newman's avatar
Rick Newman
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid

Heady days for artificial intelligence are getting headier. The giant AI startup Anthropic, maker of the Claude agent, will go public on November 19, becoming one of the biggest public offerings ever. Strong investor demand suggests the stock price could pop once it starts trading and the company’s value could approach $1.5 trillion.

Anthropic competitor OpenAI, purveyor of ChatGPT, could soon follow with its own trillion-dollar-plus IPO. These goliaths are going public four years into a stock boom largely driven by AI. Will they breathe fresh life into the rally? Or are they late to the party?

There’s a schism among investors over this question. Top traders, including Jeffrey Gundlach of DoubleLine, Jeremy Grantham of GMO, and Ken Griffin of Citadel, warn that the AI boom looks like a bubble, possibly similar to the dot-com mania of the late 1990s, which turned into a multiyear stock-market crash. The selloff in tech shares and especially AI-related stocks that began in October could be the start of such a bust.

But many others think current stock valuations are reasonable, with AI likely to produce widespread productivity gains that could boost stock values for years. Harvard professor Jason Furman, who was the top White House economist during President Barack Obama’s second term, ran some numbers recently to test just how bubbly the current market is. The results are fairly reassuring.

[Take The Weekly WTF Quiz: How much do you know about the Nvidia scandal?]

Furman compared several different types of financial metrics today with levels from the peak of the dot-com boom, which occurred in March 2000. By most measures, valuations were far more stretched back then than they are now. “Just because many past technologies have ended in bubbles does not mean it is a bubble now,” Furman wrote.

One of the things Furman looked at is stock prices and profitability in both periods, typically known as the price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E. A high P/E ratio means a stock’s price is high relative to its earnings, which could be a sign of a bubble. A lower P/E ratio suggests the company has ample earnings to justify the stock price. P/E ratios vary widely by industry and there are no absolute good or bad numbers. But within an industry or sector, they can tell you if an asset or asset class seems overvalued relative to historical trends.

[Where the Nvidia spying scandal is heading next]

Furman compared bellwether firms of the dot-com bubble with companies that might be considered analogs (pun intended 😏) in the current AI boom. Cisco, for instance, produced much of the gear meant to carry Internet traffic in 2000. At the peak of the boom in March of 2000, its P/E ratio was a stratospheric 213. Nvidia, which builds complex AI processors, is the Cisco of the AI boom. Yet its P/E ratio is just 21.

We decided to chart the then-and-now P/E ratios for each of the major industry groups included in the S&P 500 index. Here’s how current P/E ratios compare with those of the dot-com boom:

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Pinpoint Press, with Rick Newman to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Rick Newman · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.