4 Comments
User's avatar
annapolis73's avatar

Merely raising taxes and/or reodering the share of gains to reward labor versus capital will not fix this. That is the paradox which it appears that Democrats may have embraced. It is a canard.

That said, we have more than ample "wealth" as a nation to solve this. Your essay makes excellent proof of that.

The bigger problem is that the U.S is extremely wasteful of our resources. We also do not plan very well. It can even be argued that the politicians and media have been the only beneficiaries of this model of bickering and cleavage.

If we were to work together at the Federal level to incentivize long term investment in a national policy that resembles Germany or dare I say it, China, we'd be much better off. More emphasis on STEM education, less on "social influencer" sports and entertainment, with a tax code that put value on savings and investment.

P.S. A healthier workforce is a net positive for efficiency. So, universal coverage in combination with the above can pay for itself almost from the jump.

What this really takes is "cooperation." For the last 50 years, the U.S sucks at it. Please note as the Janis Joplin song notes: "Freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose." Not well postiioned!

Freddie Baumgartner's avatar

The biggest thing i heard you say is we think people should fend for themselves.I agree but,when to we start caring for the middle class. Obama 's program was okay and, could have been a starting point for better health care but , Trump made it a political issue and has done his best to get rid of the program. Trump has nothing in mine except to make the rich just richer.It is time for people to start caring about everyone and, not just who you like.Nothing but total waste.I will always be a capitalist but,all this finger pointing is a waste of time.Have you ever seen the capitalist pull the plug on Wall Street for politician's while they are in office. That just want pass.You no why? It has nothing to do with capitalism.

Double-A's avatar

Excellent starting point. Agree on essentially all your points and with most of what @annapolis73 has said. This is an extremely important post. I can think of a few other issues we need to address in our country (low civic awareness & engagement; folks not bothering to check facts before voting and then saying 18 months later that that's not what they voted for; it's like being on a long flight and opting for a literal crap sandwich with broken glass in it bc they don't like chicken Kiev, the only other option on the menu), but those have less to do with fixing capitalism.

Capitalism should stay but move farther away from the "unfettered" end of the spectrum to somewhere reasonable so that we get the desired outcomes of less oligarchic behavior (the super-rich influencing elections and then gov't [executive & legislative] decisions on regulation, incentives, taxation, anti-trust enforcement, etc), less income/wealth disparity (addressing the general affordability crisis faced by a large portion of our population), adequate and more cost-effective healthcare coverage for all, etc.

While corporate taxation need not be raised back to pre-2017 levels, the favorable tax treatment of 'long-term' capital gains (as currently defined) has to stop, with one exception: when a company issues *new* shares (IPO or later), then an investor holding those new shares (bought directly from the company or its agent) for at least 3 years (ideally 5 years; definitely not just 1 year like now) should benefit from a lower tax rate on gains from a sale. All other capital gains should be taxed like ordinary income. The idea behind lower rates for LTCG was that investors would be incentivized to invest in companies for the long term and help the companies get off the ground and build businesses. An investor selling already-issued 'old' shares of an existing company has ZERO impact on the finances of that company -- it's simply a matter of shares changing hands within the investment community. Thus such LTCG should be treated as ordinary income. This would personally hurt me bc of our holdings in taxable brokerage accounts, but it's the right thing to do.

Re: the cartoon... as a foreign student here 40 years ago, the joke was that "Don't Walk" means you're allowed to run across (at your own risk ofc!).

CTYankee 1620's avatar

Great points. Though one needs to consider the impact of the pre-tax savings accounts (which have heavily influenced equity markets for 20 years now) regarding incentives for long term gains. I would be interested to see what portion of the market is pre-tax.

I think that checks and balances to control fraud and abusive financial practices (i.e. our various anti trust acts and various SEC laws) are absolutely essential and are not being enforced right now. It’s more like keeping a leash on capitalism than fixing it.